Welcome to New York Bagels
At New York Bagels, located in Mill Valley, CA, tradition meets flavor. This family-run gem specializes in making authentic, freshly baked bagels, reminiscent of the bustling bagel shops of New York City. Their menu boasts a delightful range of options, from classic bagels topped with flavored cream cheese to hearty breakfast sandwiches and classic cold bagel creations. Customers rave about the warm, inviting atmosphere and efficient service, which makes even busy mornings feel relaxed. Whether you opt for a luscious lox sandwich or a nostalgic chocolate chip bagel, every bite celebrates the essence of New York flavor in a cozy California setting.
-
Redwood Highway Frontage Rd #215, Mill Valley, CA 94941 Hotline: (415) 381-3599
Welcome to New York Bagels, a delightful bagel shop nestled in the heart of Mill Valley, California, on Redwood Highway Frontage Rd. This charming eatery has become a local favorite, cherished for its authentic bagels and delicious breakfast sandwiches. With a phone call away at (415) 381-3599, you're on your way to an unforgettable culinary experience.
What sets New York Bagels apart is its commitment to quality and freshness. Each bagel is baked to perfection, light and fluffy, evoking the classic New York-style bagels that originated on the streets of Manhattan. The cozy atmosphere is perfect for enjoying everything from bagels with cream cheese to heartier delights like their breakfast burrito, which comes generously filled with egg, refried beans, and salsa for just $11.65.
- Bagel Offerings: Choose from a mouthwatering selection of bagels, including everything from classic varieties to their unique chocolate chip bagel. A baker's dozen is priced at an incredible $25.00.
- Cold Bagel Sandwiches: The cold bagel sandwiches do not disappoint. Try the Great White Tuna or the Lox Sandwich, featuring nova lox and cream cheese, both priced around $12.75 to $15.00.
- Fresh Cream Cheeses: Elevate your bagel experience with flavored cream cheeses like strawberry and maple walnut, complementing the bagels beautifully.
Customers rave about their experiences. Philip K. recalls visiting since childhood, highlighting the exceptional quality and reasonable prices. Kim G. acknowledges the super fresh ingredients and efficiency, while Scarlett H. connects with the rich history and authenticity that these bagels represent. The warm aroma that fills the shop is just as inviting as the friendly and efficient service, even during busy hours.
The straightforward yet satisfying menu at New York Bagels is designed for the everyman, avoiding pretentious flair while offering genuine flavors. Regulars appreciate the bustling environment, and you’ll likely find yourself returning regularly, whether for a breakfast sandwich or a leisurely afternoon bagel with cream cheese.
Whether you’re a Mill Valley local or just passing through, New York Bagels is a true gem that promises an authentic taste of New York in every bite. Come hungry, and leave satisfied!
I have been coming here since I was a kid and everything they make is outstanding! They have a great selection of bagels and freshly made cream cheeses all of which are perfect. Can get pretty busy on weekend mornings but even then the wait is hardly ever longer than five minutes. They are a family run business and one of the only places you can find a chocolate chip bagel. Literally everything is worth a try here, and even better they still charge a very reasonable price far below the trendier bagel shops in the bay.
First time here - we will definitely be back. I had a toasted sesame bagel with lox spread - delicious. Super fresh bagel and large chunks of lox in the spread. Absolutely perfect. Hubby had the breakfast burrito. He loved it, especially the beans cuz they tasted like ranch-style beans. Filling and priced right. Busy place but staff is so efficient that it moves along nicely. So glad we happened across this gem.
Walking into a warm watering smell of goodness. Ordered the Cheese beagle breakfast with bacon and American cheese. Delicious and my tummy stopped rumbling. Wash it it down with a hot French vanilla cup of fresh made coffee.
Decent bagels and super quick service. I got a bagel with turkey and cheese and it somehow ended up being $10 which is kinda crazy. Was a solid bagel and I'd come by again if I'm nearby, but def wouldn't go out of my way to come back.
Fast, efficient, clean, friendly, and absolutely dependable. These aren't fancy artisan bagels with English lager and lavender infused in the dough. These are basic down-to-earth bagels made for the Everyman and if you judge the product on these terms, no one, absolutely no one does it better!
Thus little gem was introduced to me. They have the freshest bagels being made. They have selections of what they can make for your breakfast or lunch meal. The service is great, looks like only 2 individuals were working when I went in on Saturday at 130pm. There are seating inside and outside the shop and they can quickly make your order quickly. Clean and ambiance is very casual.
Love the place Comfortable , but small 4/5 table, one outdoor Breakfast/ Brunch within Strawberry shopping center in Millvalley. Don't know if anyone can ever beat the level of extraordinary restaurants located in and around NYC. Bagels were first created in lower East Side of Manhattan Cre Orthodox Jewish Hts. Of Brooklyn mell as w Bagels are traditional Jewish favorites here are Onion and the Everything bagel. staple of Brooklyn anytime but definitely for breakfast thru 2:30 is recreated here . Enjoy !
the most real, authentic bagels in the bay area (but the bialy not real, tasty, but unauthentic). very good loX, too. B.XL.
Though the wait was long, the bagels were fluffy and delicious. The bacon egg and cheese sandwiches looked like they were just reheated egg, which is why I ordered a bagel with cream cheese, which was fantastic! They had fun cream cheese flavors, like strawberry and maple walnut which were very sweet.